King really is a terrific short-story writer. I don’t think that all novelists are really able to craft great short stories, and maybe it’s a surprise that King is so good at it, given how long some of his books are, and how much build-up he tends to put in them. However, his shorts don’t really lose anything in their size. What he is maybe forced to leave out adds rather than subtracts. Now we have to wonder a bit more. We have to think about things, and what’s happening, and why it’s happening. Which makes for a great reading experience.
For the most part. There are a few stories in Skeleton Crew that, for me, really fall short. So let’s discuss!
THE GOOD:
“The Mist” OK, maybe this has been done before, and often. Strange mist, weird creatures, certain death! But King doesn’t just give you monsters–he gives you characters. You get to know David, and Steff, and Billy, and Norton, and really, the whole town. You get their history, their hopes, and now, their fears. These aren’t strangers trapped in a supermarket. These are your friends and neighbors. And you want them to get out.
This got movied not too long ago, but they RUINED the ending. Absolutely ruined it.
“The Monkey” I am now on a quest to find a cymbal monkey. There are a ton listed on eBay, but I’m scouring local antique shops. Hopefully it’s not the same one from the story…
“The Jaunt” King ventures into SF territory with this one. And even though he never really gets into the science part, he manages to build a very realistic version of teleportation. This one is awesome, and really makes you wonder–would you hold your breath as well?
“The Raft” ALWAYS, always tell someone where you are going!!
“The Man Who Would Not Shake Hands” A return to that strange men’s club from Different Seasons. I’m pretty sure that I had mentioned that I would love to see some other stories set there–apparently I had forgotten about this one. “It is the tale, not he who tells it.”
“Beachworld” ANOTHER SF story! And seriously cool and tense. The name pretty much gives you an idea…
“The Reaper’s Image” A haunted mirror story–and like I said in the intro, often with King’s shorts, it’s what he leave out that really makes the story. This is one of the scariest in the book.
“Survivor Type” Oh man. Two questions–how badly do you want to live? And–how much trauma can you take? It’s like SAW, only solo!
“Gramma” Hands-down, the scariest story in the collection. Oh jeez. This one seriously creeped me out. And I’ve read this book before, and really had no memory of this one. As you are reading, you really aren’t sure which direction it’s going, what kind of story it is. And then BAM! at the end…
THE BAD:
“Here There By Tygers” I honestly just don’t get this one. From the whole “I have to go to the basement” to the fact that there is a tiger in the bathroom, this just does not work for me.
“Paranoid: A Chant” This one’s a poem, and I will admit, poetry is not really my deal, with very few exceptions.
“For Owen” Again, a poem, and one that seems very personal (to King’s son). Nice, but just not my thing.
The Milkman stories–I just don’t get them. How could a pyscho milkman keep his route? And it’s obvious that people are suspicious, since Rocky knows that Spike kills people… how was this guy not fired?
“The Reach” A ghost story? Sort of? This one just plain lost me as a reader, and I could not get into it.
THE REST:
“Cain Rose Up”, “Nona” These are sort of similar, in that they end with young men going on killing sprees. “Nona” seems like it might be a ghost story, but I get the feeling that it’s really more mental illness–schizophrenia. And same goes for “Cain Rose Up”. It’s easy to think that these kids were just killers, but I think that there is much more going on.
“Mrs Todd’s Shortcut”, “The Wedding Gig”, “Word Processor of the Gods”, “Uncle Otto’s Truck” These were all good stories, but for me, that was just what they were–good stories. Nothing wrong with that, but these didn’t impact me like the ones above.
There are a couple of Castle Rock stories in here, where we learn that Joe Camber and his dog are still the talk of the town, and we get to see an older Vern Tessio, as well as Ace Merrill. So we’ve got a few King connections. And even though there are a handful of stories in here that I don’t particularly care for, the others more than make up for it.